HUD hit with class action lawsuit over plan to cut funding to mixed-status households

A coalition of tenant and immigrant rights groups has filed a federal class action lawsuit seeking to block a new rule that would eliminate housing assistance for families with mixed immigration status.

Under the existing policy, “mixed-status” households could receive prorated assistance from the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) based on the number of household members who qualify.

The new rule would eliminate that assistance by amending Section 214 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1980. It would require HUD to verify that every applicant and tenant in a Section 214-covered program, regardless of age, is a U.S. citizen or has eligible immigration status.

Advertisement

The plaintiffs call the rule “unlawful and unconstitutional,” arguing that it violates Section 214, the Administrative Procedure Act and the Fifth Amendment’s guarantees of equal protection and due process.

In a statement provided to Scotsman Guide, HUD Secretary Scott Turner said the rule change “ends the exploitation of taxpayer dollars.”

“This rule guarantees ONLY AMERICAN citizens and certain eligible noncitizens will reside in HUD-funded housing,” Turner wrote. “This change represents a reallocation of up to $218 million which will now go to eligible Americans that are currently on a waitlist.”

The lawsuit was filed Thursday in U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts by the National Housing Law Project, The Legal Aid Society, LatinoJustice PRLDEF, Winston Taylor LLP, Greater Boston Legal Services and the Massachusetts Law Reform Institute.

The action was brought on behalf of Jane Does and associational plaintiffs, including the Massachusetts Union of Public Housing Tenants, Fall River Housing Joint Tenants Council, Border Workers United and the Smith Houses Resident Association.

“The complaint charges that the rule is fueled by anti-immigrant bias, deliberately targeting all immigrants — especially Latino families, who make up nearly 90% of those at risk of losing assistance,” stated the National Housing Law Project.

“Mass Union is proud to include many immigrant families in our membership,” said Dave Underhill, board chair for Massachusetts Union of Public Housing Tenants and a public housing tenant in Fall River, Mass. He called the rule “not only deplorable, but counter to what the law has been for decades.”

National Housing Law Project Managing Attorney Marie Claire Tran-Leung accused President Donald Trump and Turner of exploiting economic crises to “sow division, scapegoat immigrants, and destroy the federal housing programs.”

“That’s why we’re taking them to court,” Tran-Leung said. “We’re ready to fight alongside our immigrant neighbors to keep families whole and housed.”

Lucy Newman, supervising attorney in the public housing unit at The Legal Aid Society, called the rule unlawful and inhumane.

“HUD is disregarding our client’s constitutional rights and decades of well-established law, is ignoring overwhelming public opposition, and has admitted the rule will cost hundreds of millions of dollars without easing the housing crisis,” Newman said. “With our partners, we bring this class action litigation to put an end to this dangerous and unlawful policy before it causes irreparable harm to tens of thousands of families across the country.”

When HUD presented the rule as a proposal for public feedback, the response was overwhelmingly negative. An unscientific Scotsman Guide hand-count of responses HUD had received by the proposal’s April 21 comment submission deadline found about 97% of respondents were opposed to the change.

Published on Nov. 12, the final rule is scheduled to take effect Dec. 12.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *