FINRA Fines Spartan Capital $3.2M on Pre-IPOs
The New York-based Spartan Capital Securities will pay $3.18 million to settle charges from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority that it fell short in its oversight and disclosure obligations when recommending private placements in pre-initial public offering companies.
As part of the settlement, Spartan Capital will pay $2.18 million in restitution to customers and a $1 million fine. Additionally, Spartan’s majority owner and former CEO, John Lowry, was fined $25,000 and suspended for two years, while former acting chief compliance officer, Kim Monchik, was barred from any member firm going forward.
According to FINRA Enforcement Head Bill St. Louis, the firm “failed to conduct reasonable due diligence and, together with its former executives, provided misleading information about markups that benefitted entities controlled by its CEO.”
Spartan was registered with FINRA in 2008 and has approximately 80 registered representatives working out of its New York City headquarters, as well as two branch offices on Long Island.
Pre-IPO private payments can allow retail investors to gain exposure to private companies expected to go public and often involve funds that pool investors’ money to acquire shares or future interests in those companies.
However, this means investors are one step removed from the IPO; they often hold interests in funds rather than directly owning shares of soon-to-be-public firms. In the case of Spartan, the firm’s clients purchased interest in the Atlas Funds, which Lowry created and owned while running Spartan, which acted as the sole placement agent for them.
Between March and October 2021, Spartan recommended 344 investments in the Atlas Funds totaling about $24 million to 186 clients, many of whom were retail investors. In turn, Atlas Funds invested in other pre-IPO funds called SP Venture Funds, managed by StraightPath Venture Partners.
Lowry was the sole agent negotiating Atlas Funds’ work with SP Venture Funds, and he directed Atlas Funds to charge client markups between 13% and 36% above the amount Atlas Funds paid for its interest in the SP Venture Funds, in addition to already-disclosed placement and management fees. Clients were allegedly told the Atlas Funds wouldn’t share in any profits from the markups.
According to FINRA, Spartan and Monchik didn’t conduct due diligence on StraightPath to determine whether it actually had access to the touted pre-IPO companies, nor did they investigate its operating history, its principals or the offerings’ pricing (including whether StraightPath applied its own markups to the offerings it sold).
Additional due diligence may have identified issues with StraightPath and its owners.
In 2024, the Securities and Exchange Commission charged several StraightPath sales agents with unregistered broker activity (including selling membership interest in LLCs that purportedly invested in shares of pre-IPO companies).
Earlier this year, three of StraightPath’s founders and operators were sentenced to 11, 10 and eight years in prison for obstruction of justice. The Justice Department claimed the pre-IPO ventures were a scheme to defraud investors using “boiler room”-style call centers.
Though they claimed there’d be no upfront fees, the defendants acquired the shares and, in many cases, resold them at “arbitrarily inflated markups without disclosure.” In other cases, the firm sold interests in funds it didn’t actually possess or in pre-IPO companies it didn’t have access to. FINRA clarified that this scheme was unrelated to its charges against Spartan.
Additionally, Spartan, Lowry and Monchik fell short in disclosing who benefited from the markups on the purported pre-IPO purchases. According to FINRA, Spartan’s documents stated a third-party affiliate would sell interests to the Atlas Funds at a markup, but Atlas wouldn’t share in the profits.
However, the Funds did end up charging investors markups after purchasing the interests directly from StraightPath (with Lowry, who owned both Atlas and Spartan, pocketing profits from the exchange). The disclosures also didn’t disclose Lowry’s ownership and financial interests, nor did they indicate that Monchik was responsible for Spartan and the Atlas Funds.
Spartan did not respond to requests for comment prior to publication. All the parties consented to the FINRA settlement, without admitting or denying the findings.
Last year, FINRA charged Spartan with failing to address “glaring red flags” of churning by its reps, which generated about one-third of the firm’s overall revenue between 2018 and 2022. According to FINRA, the firm’s reps excessively traded 114 accounts, including 35 that were “churned” (in which a rep excessively buys and sells securities in a client account to boost their commission).