Brokers say lenders failing to keep pace with rise in non-standard borrowers
For 88% of brokers, lenders have been too slow to keep up with borrowers’ non-standard financial circumstances, showed research from Nottingham Building Society.
Some 68% of mortgage brokers expect these kinds of borrowers to become the new normal. This view was previously shared by one broker, Dan Gracie of Pavilion Finance, who emphasised the increasing number of complex borrowers who sat between conventionally standard and specialist lending.
Published in The Nottingham’s The Doorstep Divide report, the survey of over 500 brokers found almost a third (31%) already saw these borrowers with non-standard circumstances as the ‘norm’, with a further 49% expecting that within the next 12 months.
The sizeable majority of brokers, 90%, believed lenders should prioritise products for a wider range of borrowers’ financial circumstances.
Borrowers perceive higher risk
The mutual carried out separate consumer research that corroborated their findings from brokers.
For 58% of those surveyed, they believed those with non-traditional incomes were judged more harshly than people in conventional salaried jobs. A further 66% felt variable or irregular income was treated as higher risk, subsequently making it harder to secure a mortgage.
Grasping the next buy to let opportunities
Sponsored by Aldermore
As such, just 27% of adults said the mortgage application process was a level playing field whilst only a quarter of respondents thought individuals with non-traditional incomes were treated fairly by lenders.
Aaron Shinwell, chief lending officer at Nottingham Building Society, said: “Brokers and consumers are describing the same gap from different sides of the mortgage process. People want a fair chance to explain how they earn, what has changed and where they are now. Brokers need clarity about what evidence is required and confidence that a nuanced case will reach someone able to consider the full picture.”
To ensure a wider industry effort, Shinwell said: “We are asking lenders, brokers, and the wider industry to be clearer and more consistent about how complex income is assessed, give proper weight to rental history and work collectively to improve fair access for borrowers whose circumstances do not fit a standard model.”
Sue Hayes, chief executive officer at Nottingham Building Society, said: “The mortgage market has changed, but too often lending criteria has not kept pace with modern-day living. Life events such as divorce, bereavement, illness or changing careers are now part of many people’s stories, yet borrowers in these circumstances can still find themselves overlooked.”