CarMax and Carvana Face Off as Used-Car Buying Moves Online

The king of America’s big-box automotive retail space is reportedly facing a challenge to its throne.

That’s according to a report Sunday (Nov. 15) from The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) on the rivalry between CarMax and its digital challenger Carvana.

The report noted an apparent dig at his competitor last month by Carvana CEO Ernie Garcia III, who said during an earnings call that his company is “knocking on the door” of becoming the largest used-car retailer in the U.S.

CarMax CEO Keith Barr shrugged off the comparison in an interview with WSJ, saying that there won’t be “one winner and one loser” in the space.

“We’re going to be one of the largest retailers in the United States in the used-car industry for years to come,” Barr added.

WSJ characterizes the rivalry as part of a broader debate on the future of automotive sales. Will phone apps become the chief way people purchase vehicles? Or do consumers still want to visit a dealership and test drive a car before spending tens of thousands of dollars?

CarMax is banking on the former, the report said, with 260 dealerships covering most of the U.S., along with online-only sales.

However, the company is in the midst of a turnaround effort echoing Carvana, which lets customers find a car, arrange financing and schedule a delivery all online. Jeff Lick, an analyst at investment bank Stephens, said Barr is wise to take a page from his rival company.

“Great leaders have no ego when it comes to good ideas,” Lick said. “If your competitor is doing something new or unique or better than you, then just copy them.”

The report added that this increasing competition is happening as more drivers are opting for used cars, as the cost of a new car has jumped to roughly $50,000 on average. At the same time, a forecast last month by Cox Automotive showed the cost of used cars dipping.

Meanwhile, research by PYMNTS Intelligence shows that many consumers have been putting off major purchases.

The PYMNTS Intelligence report “Keeping Up Gets Harder: Debt Confidence Falls Among Bill Payers” found last month that 20% of consumers had delayed a major purchase in the previous 90 days, while 11.1% had canceled one. Those figures were up from a respective 18.3% and 9.6% in August.

“Among consumers who traded down, delayed or canceled a major purchase, 34.9% cited high prices as their main reason, about twice the 17.6% who said they were waiting for a better deal or better timing,” PYMNTS wrote last week.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *