Metallurgical coal is booming – should you invest?
Metallurgical coal has spent the past few years as the industrial commodity nobody wanted to admit owning. It sits under the same coal label as the thermal coal that funds have been told to divest from, even though it does an entirely different job. Capital has stayed away, generalist investors have ignored it, and the sector has traded as if the world were quietly winding it down.
That is starting to look like a mistake. The metallurgical coal price has rallied from $224 a tonne to $282 in a few weeks, and the equities have followed. The median move across the listed coal group is close to 25%. This looks like the first sign of a market waking up to something that has been true for some time – metallurgical coal is structurally indispensable, and the world simply doesn’t have enough of it.
Start with what metallurgical coal actually is, because the name causes endless confusion. This is not the thermal coal that gets burned in power stations. Metallurgical, or coking, coal is an industrial input. It goes into a blast furnace alongside iron ore, and through a chemical process that has not meaningfully changed in a century, and becomes the coke that reduces iron ore to metallic iron. There is no other input that does this job at scale. If you want steel, and the world wants a great deal more steel, you need metallurgical coal.
Sign up to Money Morning
Don’t miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
Don’t miss the latest investment and personal finances news, market analysis, plus money-saving tips with our free twice-daily newsletter
This is where the demand story gets interesting, because it is not really a China story any more – it is an India story. India’s National Steel Policy targets 300 million tonnes of crude steel capacity by 2030, roughly double where the country is today. That target is not aspirational chatter, it is showing up in blast-furnace construction across five states. My own modelling shows India’s blast furnace capacity rising from around 99 million tonnes a year in 2025 to 197 million by 2030.
Run the standard conversion of roughly 0.8 tonnes of coking coal per tonne of crude steel through that, and you get somewhere in the region of 78 million tonnes of additional gross coking-coal demand once those furnaces are running flat out. However you cut it, the direction of travel is the same: materially higher.
India knows this is its weak point. The country imports 85% of its coking coal today, and the stated policy objective is to bring that down to 65% by 2030 through domestic washing and beneficiation (techniques designed to strip impurities from coal and metal ores). Even if that target is hit in full, absolute import volumes are still likely to rise because the base demand is growing so much faster than domestic supply can be brought on. India is diversifying away from its historic reliance on Australia, buying more from the United States, Russia, Canada and Mozambique, and state-owned groups have been in talks about acquiring Russian coking-coal assets outright.
Meanwhile, supply has been shrinking. Years of capital starvation induced by the trend towards environmental and social governance (ESG), permitting delays and genuine geological depletion in premium Australian basins have left the seaborne market thin. Add in diesel-driven cost inflation in Appalachia and Australia, worsened by Middle East oil disruption, and you have a supply side that cannot respond quickly to a demand shock. That asymmetry – fast-growing structural demand against supply that takes years and enormous capital to expand – is precisely the set-up that produces the kind of price move we’ve just seen. It should persist for years.
None of this means coal prices run in a straight line from here. A benchmark of $282 will attract new supply eventually; it always does. But the mistake I see investors making is treating this as a short-covering bounce in an unloved sector. It is not. It is a repricing of a genuine structural mismatch between where steel demand is heading, particularly in India, and where metallurgical coal supply actually is. The market has been asleep on this trade for a long time. It is now stirring. I would rather be early to that than early to leave it.
The large, liquid metallurgical coal producers are the first port of call. Alpha Metallurgical Resources (NYSE: AMR) and Warrior Met Coal (NYSE: HCC) are the two most relevant US-listed groups: low-cost, high-quality producers with the operating leverage to a rising benchmark that has driven their share prices up sharply already this month.
Peabody Energy (NYSE: BTU) gives broader diversified exposure across both metallurgical and thermal coal, while Ramaco Resources (Nasdaq: METC) offers a smaller play on the same rally. All of them benefit mechanically as the benchmark price climbs, and all of them remain cheap against where metallurgical coal pricing looks to be heading over the next few years.
My own top pick sits a little further down the market-capitalisation scale: Clinch Resources (Toronto: CLCH). Clinch is bringing new North American metallurgical coal supply into production at exactly the moment the market has turned, with surface output already running at its Lanes Branch mine in West Virginia and underground production ramping up into the autumn. Production looks poised to climb from under 400,000 clean tons in the 2025-2026 fiscal year to roughly two million clean tons in 2027.
Our fair-value estimate, based on a $240-a-tonne benchmark that the market has already blown through, points to C$2.50 in the base case and C$3.90 in the bull case, against today’s share price of around C$1.05. The firm also boasts a stake in JJ Resources’ high-value coal project, and an early-stage rare-earths angle in leftover rock waste from previous mining activities, neither of which the market is pricing in at all yet.
This article was first published in MoneyWeek’s magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.
