Survey: Buyers Would Choose Smaller Homes to Get the Perfect Neighborhood
In Cotality’s Q3 2026 Consumer Sentiment Survey of recent and prospective homebuyers, approximately 56% said they would consider a less-than-ideal home if it meant living in the right place. As most buyers show openness to compromising on the home when circumstances are right, housing professionals have greater reason than ever to ask what “belonging” means to each buyer.
The survey found that millennials are the most willing to reconsider their home-buying priorities to secure a preferred location. Three in four (74%) say they would pay more for a sense of belonging, while 66% would settle for a less-than-ideal home. Among Baby Boomers, the corresponding figures are 58% and 43%.
“If the buyer reconsiders a home because they want to stay in a specific area, rerun the budget with them. Ask which costs are fixed and which are flexible,” said Kevin Greene, General Manager of Real Estate at Cotality. “Any willingness to compromise tells us little about what they can afford.”
How much buyers value the neighborhood relative to the home itself can shape budget discussions. A lender can help a borrower review the property they are considering and the expenses they have identified. An insurer can urge the buyer to obtain a quote specific to the property while alternatives are still available.
Buyers Seeking a Sense of Community
After envisioning an ideal neighborhood, it must also feel right. People want a sense of belonging, though its meaning varies from person to person. Some 69% say they would pay more for a strong feeling of belonging. Only 14% opt for the highest level of neighborhood involvement, while 87% value privacy. Meanwhile, 81% prefer a middle ground.
Although the reasons for these rankings are often highly personal, the survey revealed several clear shared preferences among this broad middle group: Roughly 67% would pay more for a sense of belonging, an estimated 56% would accept a home that is less than ideal, and 85% view privacy as important. Feeling at home requires being surrounded a variety of viewpoints. Shared outlook ranks among the strongest influences on the choice for relatively few buyers. Across the survey, 10% put similar social, cultural, or lifestyle mindsets in their top three neighborhood factors; 7% select political or religious characteristics.
What makes a neighborhood home:
| Neighborhood factor | Important | Top three influence |
|---|---|---|
| Property prices | 93% | 42% |
| Recorded crime levels | 87% | 37% |
| Personal perception of safety | 92% | 35% |
| Privacy or anonymity | 87% | 24% |
| Cleanliness, maintenance and upkeep of public areas | 91% | 23% |
| Access to work, public transport and everyday services | 83% | 22% |
| Quality of local schools | 70% | 20% |
| Noise at different times of day or night | 86% | 17% |
| Friendliness and helpfulness of neighbors | 80% | 15% |
| Whether the area is stable or changing | 87% | 14% |
| Community spirit and local events | 76% | 12% |
| Welcome for new residents | 80% | 12% |
| Mix of ages, life stages and family types | 68% | 10% |
| People with similar social, cultural or lifestyle mindsets | 68% | 10% |
| Political or faith and religious characteristics | 53% | 7% |
Privacy makes the top three for 24%. Recognizing these different perspectives on what constitutes a buyer’s sense of belonging means there is typically still much left for an agent to learn. Those who do learn how people want to belong stand to influence the final choice of buyers. Approximately 70% would pay extra for belonging, and 58% would accept a less ideal home to make that happen.
For U.S. buyers, feeling at home in a neighborhood merits early consideration during the search. About 73% would pay more for a sense of belonging—the largest proportion across the five markets—while 61% would compromise on the home itself. Agents should explore what makes a neighborhood worth these trade-offs. Lenders can help buyers assess how their preferred property may affect their budget beyond its upfront price.
Overall, getting familiar with and choosing a neighborhood takes time. Buyers may want to walk along the street after dark or visit on a weekend before deciding whether it feels like home. Across the five countries surveyed, 44% of recent and prospective buyers say today’s market forces them to make faster decisions when searching for a property. For agents, this underscores the importance of asking early what buyers need to learn about a neighborhood before visiting a home. Cotality’s Homebuyer Pressure Index stands at 40 out of 100, measuring feelings of overwhelm and urgency in finding a home, choosing a mortgage, and arranging insurance.
Agents Playing Their Part
For an agent, a buyer’s preferred area is a reason to revisit the original property brief. Ask why the neighborhood is worth compromising on home specifications and which dream-home requirements the buyer might reconsider. Document any questions that remain unanswered after the viewing. This gives the next conversation a clear purpose, whether that means arranging another visit, reviewing available property data, or clarifying the buyer’s priorities. As adoption grows, incorporating these considerations into AI platforms used throughout the buyer journey will also be essential.
Choosing a home that is less than ideal does not necessarily mean the buyer has assessed its condition or determined the cost of insuring it. Many buyers view neighborhood guidance as part of an agent’s responsibilities: Some 51% believe agents should share verified neighborhood reports. Personal observations and assistance in locating resources for lifestyle or community-related questions each receive support from 49% of buyers.
What do homebuyers say they need from real estate agents?
| Agent’s role | Consider it appropriate |
|---|---|
| Share verified neighborhood reports | 51% |
| Suggest resources and tools for lifestyle or community questions | 49% |
| Offer personal observations about the area | 49% |
| Connect buyers with residents or neighbors upon request | 36% |
Only 11% said they wanted to restrict an agent’s guidance to property specifications and legal sales transactions, excluding discussions about neighborhoods altogether. The question concerns what buyers consider appropriate; it does not imply that every buyer expects agents to provide each service.
“When a buyer says an area feels right, ask what they mean,” said Kevin Greene, Cotality’s GM of Real Estate Solutions. “Their answer can help you drill down to what they truly need in a location or property and provide the data to support or reject a property before they make an offer.”
“They were welcoming and friendly and kind of stayed out of the way of other people when needed,” said a U.S. Gen Z buyer who offered that description of their neighbors.
At first glance that may read like a recipe that leaves room for a welcome and a life of one’s own. But what feels right to the person buying the home can be difficult to capture in a property listing.
Before advising a buyer whether an area merits the additional cost or a home is worth reconsidering, an agent should first understand what the buyer has in mind. What buyers seek in order to feel a sense of belonging differs across the five markets surveyed. Respondents in the U.S. show the strongest willingness to pay extra for that sense of belonging.
To read more, click here.