Eleventh Circuit upholds CFPB rule regulating PACE loans as consumer credit

PACE loans fund home improvements like solar panels and impact windows through voluntary agreements with local governments. Homeowners repay – typically over twenty years at rates above primary mortgages – through their tax bill, secured by a lien ahead of the first mortgage. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac refuse to buy mortgages on PACE-encumbered properties. The FHA will not insure them. The Bureau’s research, covering 370,000 applications from Florida and California, found PACE loans increased mortgage delinquency probability by 35 percent. 

Building Resilient argued Congress capped the Bureau’s reach at two Truth in Lending Act (TILA) provisions in Section 307 of the 2018 Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act. Chief Judge William Pryor, writing for a unanimous panel, held Section 307 supplements the Bureau’s existing rulemaking authority – it does not replace it. The loans meet every element of consumer credit: homeowners voluntarily incur debt, repay in installments, and the money goes toward household purposes. 

The trade group also challenged the Bureau’s data. The court acknowledged imperfect data but found the regression analyses and control-group comparisons fell within the Bureau’s technical discretion. 

The constitutional argument did no better. The court drew on Supreme Court precedent to distinguish debts from taxes: a voluntary contractual obligation does not become a tax because government collects repayment through tax bills. Because the rule applies evenhandedly to government-run and privately administered programs, it does not commandeer state officials. 

One wrinkle worth watching: private PACE administrators now face civil liability under TILA when “substantially involved” in the credit decision, because the actual creditors – local governments – are immune from suit. 

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *