It’s not too late to offshore; you haven’t missed the boat

There’s an old business saying: “The pioneers get the arrows, and the settlers get the land.”

Processing Content

First movers bear the risks, costs and steep learning curve; followers move in once the path is cleared. That’s where I think we are with offshoring. 

In the early days of COVID, many firms turned to offshoring for the first time to address a severe shortage of talent. The cost savings and margin boost were just a bonus. But there was plenty of trial-and-error and firms didn’t put much thought into best practices or which country had talent that best fit their needs. They saved money anyway because the bar was low and they took any talent they could get.

But with far more firms offshoring today, those still on the sidelines worry they’ve missed the boat. The margin boost from offshoring is still there. It may not be as unique as it used to be, but you’re almost at a competitive disadvantage if you don’t offshore at all. Today offshoring is more about growth strategy than it is about adding capacity. According to the AICPA MAP Survey, nearly half (46%) of top performing U.S. accounting firms offshore some of their work. Don’t let the hype about artificial intelligence convince you it’s too late to offshore advantageously.

I recently spoke with a tax partner at a Top 100 Firm. Although Top 100 Firms were the first to offshore, starting with the Big Four in the 1990s, his firm didn’t have the same capacity issues as its peers. He told me: “Our leadership thinks we’ve maybe missed the boat on offshoring. In the early days offshoring really helped firms. But now, I don’t think it’s going to have the same impact for us.”

I explained that early offshoring was about talent scarcity, so cost savings were just a byproduct. Of course, the learning curve was steep with inconsistent results, communication challenges, rework and many unethical vendors.

Today, you may have missed the scarcity wave, but now firms see offshoring as a key part of their growth strategy. I recently spoke to the managing partner of a small New England firm that wasn’t offshoring yet. He didn’t think he could match the prices of rivals that were offshoring. In addition to lowering labor costs, he realized that offshoring allowed those firms to achieve higher profit margins, better communication with clients, faster turnaround times, plus new ways to serve clients and introduce new services.    

So no, you haven’t missed the boat on offshoring; we’re just starting to unlock its full potential. 

I tell firms, think of your biggest problems and biggest goals. Offshoring can help with both. 

For instance, say your goal is to remain independent rather than take PE money or outside partners. Offshoring can help you get the margin cushion that PE-backed competitors enjoy, without the management interference. Because your offshore team is working while you and your U.S. team sleeps, your firm can answer client questions sooner. And with routine tasks handled offshore, your onshore team is freed up for higher margin client work.

Suppose clients keep asking you to provide them with ancillary services such as bookkeeping. It’s hard to provide bookkeeping cost-effectively with your U.S. team. But, a well-trained offshore team can provide excellent bookkeeping at a much lower cost, making it affordable for clients and a profitable new revenue stream for your firm. 

AI isn’t taking over where offshoring left off; it’s enhancing it

AI is not as smart as it’s made out to be. It can be expensive and make lots of mistakes. You still need somebody to review its work, and it is only as good as the person using it. What AI is good at is discipline. Tell it to do a specific task and it will do that task every day at 5:00 a.m. without fail. It’s not going to get sick or take time off.

At a recent conference, I spoke to a firm leader about AI and offshoring. He said they wanted to experiment with AI, but not with their U.S. team. Instead, he told me they were setting up their own office in India to test various AI tools on their offshore team. “Based on the results, we’ll figure out what works best and then implement those tools throughout the firm,” he told me.

As I explained in an earlier article, AI and offshoring are not mutually exclusive. The best approach is to combine AI with offshoring. It’s all about deciding what work to give AI and what work to give people, then splitting the “people” work between your U.S. team and offshore teams.

Your U.S. team should handle client trust, judgment, sign-off and complex advisory work. Your offshore team should take on compliance, non-client-facing activities, and lower-value tasks. AI should take care of repetitive tasks and first drafts, supervised by people. Offshoring does more than the manual work that AI now handles; it adds capacity, capability and leverage that AI can’t provide alone.

Catching up to the offshoring wave without rushing into mistakes

Firms that think they’re behind the offshoring curve often ask me how to get up to speed quickly without sacrificing quality or making onboarding and implementation mistakes.

I tell them the first step is to change your mindset. You’re not playing catch-up. You are at the early stages of the “offshoring as a strategy” wave. You still have time to think things through and make the best decision. The ecosystem has matured and there’s less trial-and-error today.

Accountants and vendors now know more about how offshoring should work. There are more consultants and advisors available who have proven knowledge of the countries you’re considering. They can guide you through the process. No matter how unique you think your situation is, there’s an offshoring playbook for you to follow. You’re no longer a pioneer on the prairie starting from square one. A firm your size with similar challenges has already been through it.

Firms sometimes tell me: “Anshul. Our clients are older; they’re not going to accept offshoring.” There’s a playbook for that, too. Some firms are wary of the perception that they’re shipping American jobs overseas. There’s a playbook for that as well. 

Offshoring to compete with PE-backed firms

If you’re not ready for PE money or don’t think you ever will be, offshoring lets you pull one of the biggest levers PE uses on your own terms. The PE playbook is simple: Buy accounting firms that aren’t offshoring or using technology, then do both to improve their margins.

Even a small firm can use the same playbook your PE-backed competitors use to boost margins and valuations. But unlike those rivals, you keep control of your firm and the people you most want to retain. 

Reducing burnout

Burnout comes from having too few people to do all the work and from spending too much time on low-value, rather than high-value, tasks. That’s exactly where offshoring comes in. You expand your team at a reasonable cost and hand off tasks you don’t want your U.S. team doing, such as compliance-related work.

Your (higher paid) managers should be spending time with clients, not preparing or reviewing simple returns. They shouldn’t be doing manual entry or doing the first review of client books. They should get all the routine work done offshore and then use insights from the offshore team to serve clients better.

If you’re just starting your offshoring journey, you didn’t miss the boat. You skipped the rough first voyage. The firms winning today treat offshoring and AI as a single delivery strategy, and that race has only just begun.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *