S&P puts Colorado county on rating review for possible downgrade

Adobe Stock
Pueblo County, Colorado, is facing a potential rating downgrade after it failed to disclose until Nov. 6 short-lived debt service payment defaults that occurred months earlier.
Processing Content
S&P Global Ratings on Tuesday put the county’s A-minus long-term rating on CreditWatch negative following the disclosure of multi-series defaults on certificates of participation.
“The CreditWatch placement reflects our view there is at least a one-in-two chance that we could lower the rating based, in part, on an assessment of the county’s willingness and ability to make timely payments underlying its COPs,” the rating agency said. “We could lower the rating, potentially by multiple notches, based on our forward-looking assessment of the county’s financial performance, balance-sheet strength, and financial management practices relative to those of peers.”
The defaults, which occurred in January and March, were flagged
Under that rule, issuers must disclose material events, including debt payment defaults, no later than 10 business days after the events’ occurrence.
Robert Choi, Pueblo County’s chief administrative officer, blamed the defaults, which he said only recently came to light during due diligence for an upcoming COP sale, on several factors.
“The former (county chief financial officer) did not understand the distinction between the county’s deadline to fund the trustee and the later payment date for certificate holders, and at the time of the events, the county had no debt management plan in place, and payments were being processed manually,” he told The Bond Buyer. “There was a leadership transition at the beginning of the year, as well. Additionally, there was a Workday transition that was incomplete, so this complicated the business processes associated with debt payments.”
Workday is a cloud-based financial management software platform.
Since action was taken in October to demote the CFO, who Choi said was not aware of the obligation to file an event notice when the defaults occurred, the county
“They are operating as a strategic financial advisor, taking on many of the functions of CFO, and it remains under my authority as the chief administrative officer,” said Choi, who joined the county government in July.
As for S&P’s rating review, Choi said it was not surprising given what was discovered and finally disclosed.
January and March defaults
Jan. 1 defaults involved payments on Series 2023A COPs, which were subsequently made on Jan.16, and on payments for Series 2022A COPs that resulted in a Jan. 5 unscheduled draw on debt service reserves, which were replenished on Jan. 16, according to the Nov. 6 notice.
Payments due March 16 on Series 2009A COPs insured by Assured Guaranty, and Series 2021 A and B COPs were made on March 18. The notice pointed out the county’s base rentals payment under lease purchase agreements, which are due about 15 days prior to debt service payment dates, were not made during that timeframe.
The notice was posted a day after Pueblo County Commissioners approved revised plans for a $30 million COPs sale. The deal, which Choi said is scheduled for pricing later this month or in early December by Piper Sandler, was increased to up to $37 million in two series with $24 million of the debt insured by BAM Mutual.
Lisa Washburn, a managing director at Municipal Market Analytics, which tracks bond impairments and defaults, said S&P’s review of Pueblo County’s rating makes sense given the repeated incidences of failure to make timely payments.
“Even if it isn’t an ability to pay issue, the county’s fiscal management practices and willingness to adhere to its contractual obligations in a timely way can negatively impact credit quality,” she said in an email.
Previous rating downgrades
Choi said the defaults were not yet known when S&P and Moody’s Ratings downgraded the county’s ratings just months ago.
In August, S&P dropped the COPs rating to A-minus with a negative outlook from A-plus ahead of what was then expected to be a $30 million Series 2026 COPs sale.
S&P cited “the county’s rapid use of reserves over the last two years due to supporting ongoing capital projects, which have resulted in financial performance deterioration and a weakened available reserve position.”
Moody’s downgraded the county’s issuer rating to A2 from Aa3 and lease appropriation ratings to A3 from A1 in September. The lowered ratings were given a negative outlook, reflecting the county’s financial and operational challenges as it works to restore structural balance and rebuild reserves under a new financial management team, while transitioning to new financial software systems, according to the rating report.
Pueblo County