Borrowers With the Most Favorable Rates Realize Big Savings Throughout Loan’s Life
A favorable mortgage rate can yield substantial benefits. Borrowers securing the most competitive rates experience considerable interest savings throughout their loan term. This financial advantage enables increased capacity for savings and investment opportunities.
Which borrowers are obtaining the most favorable rates? According to a LendingTree analysis, borrowers achieving the lowest mortgage rates typically demonstrate superior credit profiles, contribute larger down payments, and evaluate multiple lender options. Additionally, these borrowers are predominantly experienced homebuyers rather than first-time purchasers.
The disparity between optimal and average mortgage rates extends significantly beyond minor basis point variations, with cumulative effects that become substantial over time.
Borrowers who obtained the lowest mortgage rates maintain an average APR of 5.52%, compared to 6.15% for the broader borrower population—representing a 0.63 percentage point differential. When applied to a $300,000 mortgage, which represents the median value in the analysis, this variance produces $121 in monthly savings and approximately $43,398 in total savings across the 30-year loan duration.
Matt Schulz, Chief Consumer Finance Analyst at LendingTree, emphasizes that although these savings are tangible and measurable, it is important to recognize that such advantages are not acquired without deliberate effort.
“The best mortgage rates generally go to borrowers who give lenders the fewest reasons to worry,” he said. “Those are typically people with strong credit, relatively low debt, steady income and a meaningful down payment. It’s easier said than done to accomplish those things, and it probably won’t happen overnight, but if you’re planning to buy a home in the near future, those should be your goals.”
Regarding the substantial down payments that such borrowers typically contribute, Schulz further observes that acquiring a five-figure financial gain presents considerable difficulty. Conversely, a comparatively straightforward and ordinarily attainable approach to accumulating savings involves dedicating effort to research and evaluate various mortgage rate offerings.
“Not everyone will save $40,000 or more by shopping around for the best mortgage rates,” Schulz said. “Your mileage will vary based on a bunch of different factors. However, you have nothing to lose and everything to gain in shopping around. After all, even if you only save $5,000 or $10,000 by shopping around, that’s an awful lot of money. That’s meaningful over time, and often all it requires is a little bit of time.”
Lowest-Rate Borrowers Buy Pricier Homes
Frequently, the most favorable interest rates are accompanied by substantial financial commitments and initial capital requirements. Properties acquired by borrowers securing the lowest rates demonstrated a median appraised value of $625,000—approximately double the $325,000 median valuation for remaining borrowers.
Initial capital contributions exhibited an equally pronounced disparity: Borrowers obtaining the lowest rates contributed a median down payment of $155,000, representing $110,000 more than the $45,000 median contributed by other borrowers. When calculated as a percentage of the purchase price, this corresponds to 20% for the lowest-rate borrowers, compared to 15% for all other borrowers.
“A larger down payment is big,” he says. “It reduces the lender’s risk because the buyer begins with more equity and borrows a smaller share of the home’s value. It may also help the buyer avoid private mortgage insurance and lower the monthly payment.”
According to Schulz, the additional capital provided at the outset performs substantial work in the transaction.
“Putting 20% down isn’t the right move for everybody,” he said. “Waiting could mean higher home prices, different mortgage rates or another year of rent. Buyers also shouldn’t empty their savings to reach a particular down payment percentage. Homeownership is expensive, and repairs have a funny way of showing up at the worst possible time.”
Creditworthiness represents a significant distinguishing factor in mortgage lending. Borrowers securing the most favorable rates demonstrate a median credit score of 755, whereas other borrowers average 727. These advantaged borrowers additionally benefit from substantially greater lender competition: 97% of lowest-rate borrowers obtained a minimum of three lending offers, in contrast to 89% of remaining borrowers. Furthermore, lowest-rate borrowers exhibited a higher propensity to apply alongside a co-borrower, representing 47% compared to 30% of other applicants.
Beyond credit scores alone, borrowers obtaining the lowest mortgage rates exhibited more robust overall credit profiles. Relative to other borrowers, they maintained lower median monthly debt obligations excluding mortgages ($371 dollars versus $505), maintained lengthier credit histories (17 versus 13 for the oldest account), and demonstrated lower median credit utilization ratios (7% versus 12%).
Schulz asserts that both components—the credit profile and the inclination to evaluate alternative offers—are of considerable significance.
“Credit scores have a major influence on the mortgage rate a borrower ultimately receives,” he said. “It helps lenders understand how likely the borrower is to repay the loan. A few points can make a difference in whether someone gets the lowest rate or has to settle for a higher one. Shopping around makes a huge difference because offers can vary really widely among lenders. Taking the time to shop around allows you to compare those offers and potentially play them off each other to score even better terms.”
| Metric | Lowest-rate borrowers | Other borrowers | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median credit score | 747 | 710 | 37 |
| Median down payment | $95,000 | $33,750 | $61,250 |
| Median loan amount | $451,250 | $261,250 | $190,000 |
| Median down payment | 20% | 10% | 10 percentage points |
| Median loan-to-value (LTV) ratio | 80% | 90% | 10 percentage points |
| Median lender offers | 7 | 4 | 3 |
Borrowers who secure the most favorable mortgage rates typically possess previous mortgage experience. Among those obtaining the lowest rates, merely 33% are first-time homebuyers, whereas 59% of remaining borrowers fall into this category.
Nevertheless, first-time buyers are not entirely excluded from accessing the most competitive rates. First-time buyers who successfully obtained the lowest rates demonstrated substantially superior performance relative to their counterparts, evidenced by a higher median credit score (747 compared to 710) and more substantial median down payments (20% relative to 10%).
“Repeat buyers often bring more resources and experience to the table,” he said “They may be able to use equity from a previous home for a larger down payment, and they’ve already been through the mortgage process once. Those advantages can help them present the type of financial profile lenders tend to reward.”
To read the full report, click here.
