Trade Groups Request That FHFA Postpone GSE Condo Reserve Increase
The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) has been asked to postpone a planned change to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac underwriting guidelines by one year that would raise condominium reserve requirements from 10% to 15%. Commentary from Eric Souza, Editor of Scotsman Guide magazine, further illustrates the action and its potential effects.
The request was made by a coalition of trade groups: the Community Associations Institute, the Community Home Lenders of America, the National Association of Mortgage Brokers, the Community Association Roundtable and the Housing Policy Council.
In a letter sent Thursday to FHFA Director Bill Pulte, the groups cited “serious concerns regarding the upcoming increase.” They stressed, however, that their request does not signal opposition to responsible reserve funding.
“Iit reflects the industry’s concern that a significant policy change with direct consequences for homeowners, condominium associations, and mortgage availability should be implemented with sufficient preparation and a clear understanding of its potential effects,” the trade groups said.
The coalition said a one-year delay would give the industry, condominium associations and other affected stakeholders time to resolve implementation challenges, better assess potential consequences and develop a more practical transition.
Note: The FHFA, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac did not immediately respond to Scotsman Guide’s request for comment.
Diving Into the Delay
The trade groups cited three main reasons for requesting the delay:
1. Implementation challenges remain:
“Significant implementation and preparedness issues remain unresolved,” the letter stated, explaining that raising the minimum reserve allocation could substantially affect association budgets, reserve studies, annual assessments, financial planning, and condominium boards’ ability to communicate and implement changes with homeowners.
“These are not minor implementation details,” the coalition said. “They directly affect whether associations can reasonably comply and whether otherwise financeable condominium projects remain eligible for conventional mortgage financing.”
2. Could affect condo financing, housing availability:
The groups cautioned that associations failing to satisfy the new reserve requirements could become ineligible for conventional financing. This could weaken buyer demand and make it more difficult for homeowners to sell or refinance.
The coalition warned that older, smaller, and lower-income communities may be disproportionately affected. A transition that overlooks their financial limitations could unnecessarily restrict condominium ownership and mortgage access for borrowers who would otherwise qualify.
3. Higher reserves could add to housing costs:
The mortgage and housing groups’ third concern is that the requirement “adds costs at a particularly difficult time for housing affordability.”
According to Fannie Mae, the higher reserve requirement could increase condominium owners’ monthly costs by about $13 to $14. However, “the actual impact will vary considerably by community,” the letter stated.
The change is scheduled to take effect on Jan. 4, 2027.