Consumer Duty in a shared ownership context – Phillips
New rulings today from the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) indirectly throw a spotlight on the role of mortgage brokers.
The advertising watchdog published three rulings on shared ownership advertisements that failed to clearly communicate the nature of shared ownership arrangements and associated costs to prospective buyers.
The fact that two of those ads recommended contacting a mortgage broker to discuss finances illustrates the essential role brokers play in ensuring that shared owners can make informed transactional decisions. But the advertising watchdog’s rulings also suggest increased regulatory attention on consumer protection for households who are considering the shared ownership scheme.
Consumer Duty: Information and outcomes
Implementing Consumer Duty requirements is not necessarily straightforward when it comes to shared ownership.
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) guidance prioritises outcomes: “We want firms to help customers make effective, timely and properly informed decisions, and present information that is fair, clear, and not misleading”, adding: “Customers should have the information they need, at the right time and presented in a way they can understand”.
Grasping the next buy to let opportunities
Sponsored by Aldermore
However, following an investigation, the National Audit Office (NAO) described shared ownership as “a complex financial and legal product for consumers”. The NAO concluded that: “Shared owners are well-informed about initial affordability, but the longer-term financial risks when buying their initial share may not be obvious“.
This clearly has implications for entrants to the scheme. In a 2026 Shared Ownership Insight report, based on an analysis of enquiry data, the Leasehold Advisory Service found that: “When shared ownership works, it works well. When it does not […] the consequences for people’s finances, their ability to move, and their wellbeing can be severe”.
A full-lifecycle approach to financial decision-making
A key theme of Shared Ownership Resources 2023 report, Shared Ownership: The Consumer Perspective, was that: “Affordability should be evaluated across the full lifecycle of the shared owner’s experience”.
Subsequent social housing sector reports, including the 2026 CIH report, Shared ownership in England: Assessing the tenure’s evolving role, increasingly emphasise the benefits of a full-lifecycle approach. But what does this mean for shared ownership brokers? In short, they need a long-term view of their clients’ circumstances. As researchers at the University of York state: “Purchasers need to undertake complex assessments of the trajectories of household income, local house prices, inflation and mortgage rates to manage housing costs over time and increase shares or equity in the home.”
It can come as an unwelcome shock to discover that, while shared ownership offers an affordable route onto the housing ladder, over the long term, it doesn’t necessarily offer good value for money, with corresponding opportunity costs.
Does it matter if shared owners don’t staircase to 100%?
In practice, relatively few shared owners staircase to 100%, largely because property prices tend to rise faster than household incomes.
However, not staircasing leaves shared owners vulnerable to compounding, above-inflation annual rent increases. Shared ownership rent is frequently described as “capped” or “subsidised”, perhaps leading many entrants to the scheme to underestimate potential rent increases in a high-inflation environment. It is for this reason that Shared Ownership Resources has published a 25-year rent calculator, allowing people to explore how rent could potentially rise in a number of different scenarios.
Service charges
A 2025 study commissioned by Leeds Building Society claimed that shared ownership was more affordable in 77% of areas during the first year, increasing to 79% by year five and 93% by year 10. However, it is vital that mortgage brokers do not place undue reliance on such findings when it comes to offering professional advice to individual clients. The Leeds Building Society study assumed that the initial service charge is 0.25% of the current market value of the property. But a review of current sales listings suggests that the 0.25% assumption may not hold true for a great many properties.
The Leasehold Advisory Service reports that service charges constitute the single-largest category of enquiry from leaseholders and shared owners alike. Even so, the situation is different for shared owners, who bear 100% liability for the costs of repairs and maintenance regardless of the size of their share – bar specified landlord contributions during a 10-year Initial Repair Period under the new model lease. This may feel particularly unfair where a shared owner has a small stake in equity, perhaps as low as 10%, and a high rent.
In its Service Charges Charter, the Greater London Authority (GLA) states: “For affordable housing tenures such as shared ownership, service charges can be the difference between housing costs being affordable or not”.
The role of shared ownership brokers
Following an inquiry into shared ownership, in 2024, the LUHC Committee concluded that it is “unacceptable for shared owners to be required to make significant financial decisions without appropriate, independent advice being readily available“. Shared ownership brokers therefore have a vital role to play in ensuring that entrants to the scheme have the information they need to make informed decisions.
Navigating the complexities of the scheme requires shared owners to have an excellent understanding of financial risk in relation to questions such as “whether the mortgage, rent and other property costs will remain affordable throughout the borrower’s ownership”, and regarding potential value for money over the long term compared to an open market purchase.