Delaware court rejects REIT’s accounting move to halve manager exit fee
Under their management agreement, Holmwood was entitled to asset management fees equal to 1.5% of the REIT’s stockholders’ equity, acquisition fees of 1.0% per property deal, and a termination fee if the REIT ended the arrangement. That termination fee equaled three times the sum of management and acquisition fees earned over the prior 24 months.
A side letter later modified the formula with equity-linked thresholds. If stockholders’ equity never reached $15 million, no termination fee was owed. If it reached $15 million but not $35 million, the fee was halved. Cross the $35 million mark, and the full 3.0x multiplier applied.
In March 2019, the REIT’s board approved a recapitalization with a new investor, Hale Partnership Capital Management, voted to terminate the management agreement effective March 31, 2020, and installed new leadership.
The new Chief Financial Officer (CFO) initially calculated stockholders’ equity above $35 million for the first two quarters of 2019 – $35,916,217 for Q1 and $37,133,134 for Q2. But when she prepared financial statements for an SEC filing later that year, she and the REIT’s auditors concluded that Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) required accruing the estimated termination fee as a liability on the books. Recording that $1,750,000 estimate dragged stockholders’ equity for Q2 2019 from $37,133,134 down to $34,904,007 – just below the $35 million line. Every calculation after that stayed below the threshold, and the REIT calculated the termination fee using the lower 1.5x multiplier.
The court ruled this was wrong. Under the management agreement’s definition of stockholders’ equity, non-cash items that impacted GAAP-reported equity had to be excluded. The termination fee estimate was exactly that – a non-cash accrual. No cash changed hands until March 2020. The estimate had to be added back.