KeyBank satisfied a mortgage it still wanted to collect and lost
The problems started early. KeyBank moved for a default judgment after the defendants failed to respond. But under New York law, a default isn’t an automatic win. The lender still has to lay out the facts supporting its claim – either through a verified complaint or a supporting affidavit. KeyBank did neither effectively. The amended complaint was unverified, and it offered only what the court called a “conclusory allegation” that the satisfaction had been filed in error. The banking officer’s affidavit submitted in support of the motion didn’t even address the satisfaction of mortgage.
The court denied the default judgment.
From there, the question of whether the satisfaction was truly erroneous went to a limited nonjury trial before a Judicial Hearing Officer, referred on the parties’ consent.
KeyBank put up one witness – a banking officer. That witness testified he was not part of the internal review team that had examined the relevant account and made the determination about the satisfaction. He also testified he did not have access to that team’s records. The bank’s only witness couldn’t speak to the central question: was the satisfaction of mortgage actually filed by mistake?
The JHO found the witness lacked personal knowledge and ruled that KeyBank had not submitted sufficient evidence to justify vacating the satisfaction. The Appellate Division agreed, holding that the JHO’s determination was supported by a “fair interpretation of the evidence” and should not be disturbed – the standard for overturning a nonjury trial verdict in New York.