‘You took yourself out of the middle of your business – then you put Alex there’ – Flavin


Three years ago, you were writing every complex case yourself.

Answering every introducer call. Taking the laptop on holiday and pretending to the family you weren’t.

Then you hired properly. An experienced adviser, good with people, technically sharp. Call them Alex.

Alex took the self-employed cases. Then the later life ones. Then the introducers started ringing Alex directly, because Alex was easier to get hold of than you. You finally got your Fridays back. You haven’t written a case in months.

Now one question. What percentage of the firm’s income does Alex write?

Ask most owners and there is a long pause. Then a number. Higher than they would like.

Remortgaging landlords driving BTL activity


Sponsored

Grasping the next buy to let opportunities

Sponsored by Aldermore


That is not a business that’s got rid of its key person. That is a business that has swapped one.

And it is a worse swap than it looks. You could at least rely on yourself to turn up on Monday. Alex can hand in notice whenever it suits.

The industry tells this story as a happy one. Find a great broker and pay whatever it takes to keep them. Networks hand out awards for them. Owners talk about theirs at conferences the way other people talk about their kids.

I think we have got it the wrong way round. An adviser writing 40% of your income is not your biggest asset. It is a concentration risk you’re paying full whack to keep.

 

Things move quickly

This is exactly the moment it bites.

Back in September, Moneyfacts had the average five-year fix at 6% on Monday. First time since September 2023. At the start of September, there were 1,494 deals priced under 5%. By the following month, nine.

Markets like this send the hard cases to whoever can actually do them. And every firm in your town knows who that is.

So who gets the phone calls when firms get nervous? My bet is it isn’t your trainee. It is the adviser with the following. A bigger split somewhere else, or a consolidator that wants a name with introducers attached.

 

The specifics

Let’s put a number on it.

A five-adviser firm. £600,000 per year of income. Alex writes £240,000 of it. Around £150,000 comes through three estate agents and an accountant, who all know Alex by first name.

Alex’s contract probably says no soliciting your clients. Go and check whether it says anything about introducers. Plenty do not. And even when they do, nobody can stop an estate agent picking up the phone to someone they like.

Alex goes, and you don’t lose £240,000 overnight. You lose the £150,000 that follows Alex over the next year, quietly, as the referrals start turning up somewhere else. You lose the complex cases your other advisers have been passing to Alex for three years, which means they still can’t do them. And you lose your Fridays, because guess who goes back to writing them.

40% of the business at risk. A quarter of it is likely gone. And nothing in your management information (MI) saw it coming, because your MI tracks how much Alex writes. It never once asked what happens if Alex stops.

Now picture a buyer looking at the same firm. They will spot the concentration in about 10 minutes. Then they will either push more of your price into an earn-out that only pays if Alex stays, or they will want Alex signed up to a retention deal before completion. Which means Alex agrees to terms before you get yours. Often both.

The trouble is, most firms make this worse without noticing.

The best leads go to Alex, because they convert them. The top split goes to Alex, because you can not risk losing them. And somewhere along the way Alex gets excused from the process. No fact find template. Protection done their own way. Everyone knows, and nobody says anything, because the numbers are good and nobody fancies the row.

So the firm’s process ends up being something only the juniors follow. The way your best cases actually get written lives in one person’s head. Which is exactly where it lived when it was yours.

 

Maximising good employees

I am not saying get rid of your best adviser. I am saying change what you pay them for.

Most top producers are rewarded on one thing: what they personally write. Every incentive in the building points at making them more central. If you want a firm rather than a star, part of what Alex earns has to come from making themselves less necessary. The complex-case process they have written down that other people now follow. The introducers who have got to know someone else in the office as well as they know Alex.

Some top producers will hate that. Fair enough. That tells you something as well. The good ones will see it as a way up. A proper senior role. Not just the busiest desk in the building.

Two things worth doing this week.

Work out what percentage of your income each adviser writes, and which introducers only ever deal with one person. If any adviser is above 25%, or any introducer relationship belongs to only one name, you’ve found your key-person risk. It is just wearing a different shirt.

Then sit down with your best adviser and ask them to write down, step by step, how they handle a self-employed case with messy accounts. Not a policy. What they actually do. If they can not, you have got a problem. If they will not, you have got a bigger one.

Most owners will not have that conversation. The person they would be having it with is the one person they’re frightened of upsetting.

Have it now. Before they have a different conversation with someone else.

You did the hard part. You got yourself out of the middle.

Do not put somebody else there and call it a business.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *