CMT Head to Head: Should rate always come first?

Mortgage borrowers rarely ask how they can pay more. But does that mean the lowest rate is always the best choice?

Head to Head

That question opened the first edition of CMT Head to Head, a new video series bringing together mortgage-industry voices with differing views on issues affecting brokers and borrowers.

The debut debate featured Ron Butler, founder of Butler Mortgage and host of the Angry Mortgage podcast, and Ryan La Haye, president of Groupe RLH, a director and mortgage broker with Planiprêt, and chief operating officer of Smith Manoeuvre Services Corporation and Strategy Hub.

CMT senior contributing writer Jared Lindzon moderated the discussion.


Rate wasn’t the real disagreement

Butler argued that rate is where most borrowers start—and often where they want the conversation to end.

“Can I get a higher interest rate? No, it doesn’t exist,” Butler said.

La Haye largely agreed, but argued that rates should only be compared after the borrower’s broader circumstances are understood. A homeowner carrying expensive unsecured debt, for example, might lower their total borrowing costs through a refinance—even if the resulting mortgage rate is higher.

“Should you always look for the best rate? Certainly—within the context in which it exists,” La Haye said.

That was the common ground. The disagreement was how much a broker should investigate before deciding which mortgage is actually the best fit.

Is “going deeper” good advice or a sales tactic?

Butler argued that most borrowers don’t need an elaborate financial strategy—just clear answers, a proper explanation of the product and its risks, and the best deal the broker can secure.

He went further, arguing that some brokers use refinancing, debt strategies or more complicated products to steer the conversation away from a rate they cannot match.

“Is going deeper a sham?” Butler asked. “Is it a method to try to entice people into either refinancing or some other kind of tomfoolery to get the conversation off rate?”

La Haye agreed that this happens, but rejected the idea that looking beyond rate is usually just a way to place a more profitable mortgage.

“Every single mortgage broker in the country should be looking at themselves in the mirror and asking themselves, ‘Am I doing this because it’s better for my client? Am I doing this because it’s better for me?’” he said.

Butler generally favours simplicity, while La Haye believes brokers should explore relevant options clients may not know to ask about, provided the risks are clearly explained.

That includes leveraged debt-management strategies, an area in which La Haye has a professional involvement through Smith Manoeuvre Services Corporation and Strategy Hub.

“Leverage cuts both ways,” he said. “Cash-flow neutral doesn’t mean risk neutral.”

What borrowers should take from it

One point was clear by the end: if a broker recommends paying more, they should be able to explain exactly why it makes sense for that borrower.

For borrowers, the exchange comes down to three questions:

  • What am I receiving in exchange for the higher rate?
  • What could this mortgage cost through penalties, restrictions or interest elsewhere?
  • Does the recommendation fit my plans and risk tolerance, or is it adding complexity I do not need?

Butler worries that complexity can be used to justify a sale, while La Haye argues that focusing too narrowly on rate can shut down a conversation worth having. Both agree that rate matters; they differ on how deeply a broker should examine the borrower’s circumstances before deciding the lowest rate is also the best fit.

Watch the full debate above to hear their examples, explore their perspectives, and understand where each draws the line.


CMT Head to Head brings together mortgage-industry voices with differing perspectives to debate issues affecting mortgage professionals and borrowers.

Visited 29 times, 30 visit(s) today

Last modified: November 16, 2026

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *