Why self-employed income deserves greater recognition in high-value lending – McCormack
A successful business does not always translate into the mortgage borrowing capacity its owner might expect.
I’m sure many advisers will have encountered self-employed clients whose companies generate substantial profits, yet whose personal earnings tell a very different story.
This can become particularly significant in higher-value mortgage cases, where differences in how lenders assess income can materially influence the options available.
The realities of self-employed income
Company directors often make deliberate decisions about how much income to withdraw, weighing their personal requirements against the needs of their businesses. Retaining profits to support expansion, maintain cash reserves or fund future investment can be a sensible commercial approach, although it may create challenges when affordability is assessed primarily against salary and dividends.
The wider financial picture can also be more involved. Applicants may hold interests in several companies, have different ownership arrangements or experience fluctuations in earnings between accounting periods.
Grasping the next buy to let opportunities
Sponsored by Aldermore
In practice, a reduction in profitability could reflect planned investment or restructuring rather than deteriorating trading conditions. Establishing the reasons behind these movements can be important when assessing the sustainability of income, especially where substantial borrowing is involved.
Recognising the value of retained profits
The treatment of profit after tax (PAT) is one area where lending criteria are evolving to better accommodate the circumstances of self-employed borrowers.
For example, we recently updated our PAT criteria to allow qualifying directors to use their proportionate share of company profits in affordability assessments, regardless of property value. In our case, applicants must own more than 50% of the business individually or jointly, with qualifying gross annual income, including PAT, of at least £75,000 for sole applications or £100,000 for joint applications.
Inevitably, lenders will take different approaches to assessing self-employed income, but there is a clear opportunity to broaden the scope for recognising underlying business earnings rather than relying exclusively on personal drawings, all while maintaining responsible lending standards. And, especially in larger mortgage cases, this could make a meaningful difference to borrowing capacity.
Understanding the business behind the borrower
How income is assessed is only one consideration when arranging higher-value mortgages for self-employed clients. The purpose of the borrowing and its relationship with the applicant’s wider business commitments can be equally important.
Consider a director planning an acquisition or significant expansion who may wish to preserve liquidity, while another might be looking to refinance an existing property without diverting capital from their business.
These circumstances can influence the timing and structure of borrowing, making early discussions with clients, their accountants and lenders particularly valuable.
Making greater flexibility count
The real opportunity for the intermediary market lies in bringing these elements together, combining a detailed understanding of the client’s business and personal circumstances with an appreciation of how different lenders assess self-employed income.
Ultimately, it’s about ensuring borrowing decisions reflect not simply the figures recorded in the accounts, but the financial strength, ambitions and longer-term objectives of the individual behind them.