CODA Markets fined $210,000 by FINRA
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) has censured CODA Markets, Inc. and fined it $210,000 for publishing 21 inaccurate monthly execution-quality reports and having no system to check them. CODA is a FINRA member broker-dealer in Wilmette, Illinois, operating an alternative trading system (ATS), a non-exchange trading venue, that provides execution and routing to broker-dealers and institutional customers. It settled through a Letter of Acceptance, Waiver and Consent (AWC) without admitting or denying the findings. Chief compliance officer Mark DeRolf signed it on Monday, Senior Counsel Manuel Yanez accepted it for FINRA on Tuesday, and FINRA’s action date is yesterday. The case began with a FINRA examination.
The reports fall under Rule 605 of Regulation NMS (National Market System), the Securities and Exchange Commission rule requiring published execution-quality statistics. Nine reports, covering June 2023 to February 2024, misclassified over 183 million orders because of a vendor coding error: primary peg immediate-or-cancel (IOC) orders were reported as inside-the-quote limit orders instead of at-the-quote. Twelve more, covering October 2024 to September 2025, wrongly included over 893 million not held orders, which give the broker discretion over time and price. In September 2024 CODA told subscribers it would accept only not held orders, but did not timely notify its vendor.
A repeat of a 2020 case
FINRA had warned CODA in May 2023 about misclassification and the lack of review. In May 2020 it censured CODA and fined it $125,000 for 89 inaccurate Rule 605 reports, covering June 2010 to October 2017, and a supervisory failure. The new fine is $85,000 higher.
The AWC finds breaches of Rule 605 and of FINRA Rules 2010, 3110(a) and 3110(b), the supervision rules. From June 2023 to September 2025 CODA ran no accuracy reviews. Its written supervisory procedures (WSPs) required none before March 2024, and the revised procedures were not followed in practice. FINRA found:
CODA lacked reasonable systems and procedures for reviewing the accuracy of its Rule 605 reports.
FINRA
CODA remediated the vendor error in March 2024. It stopped publishing Rule 605 reports in September 2025 because it handled all orders on a not held basis. After Rule 605 amendments and SEC guidance took effect in August 2026, it resumed the reports, began supervisory reviews in September 2026 and updated its WSPs in October 2026.
For firms that publish statistics produced by a vendor, the case points to three checks: that someone inside the firm reviews accuracy, that the vendor is told promptly when order handling changes, and that written procedures are followed once revised.