Millennials Had It Better Than Boomers (Until the Pandemic Changed the Math)

Buying a home can be all about timing, and that timing can span generations.

According to a new Redfin report, elder millennials who bought a home in their early 30s had it better than baby boomers did at the same age. Redfin noted that historically low mortgage rates and higher household incomes meant those millennials spent about 27% of their income on housing at age 30, compared with 36% for boomers.

Then the pandemic happened, and it changed the math.

Mortgage rates jumped from around 3% to nearly 7%, and home prices surged, Redfin said. Since rates rose above 6% in 2022, elder millennials have spent up to 35% of their income on monthly mortgage payments, compared with roughly 25% for boomers at the same age.

Redfin said that boomers might point out that mortgage rates were much higher in their day, and they’d be right.

Rates peaked at over 16% in 1981 and stayed in double digits for much of the decade. But prices were lower, Redfin noted. In the 1980s, when many boomers were in their 30s, the typical home sold for roughly $235,000 to $265,000 in today’s dollars. Redfin said that when elder millennials reached the same prime homebuying age in the 2010s and 2020s, typical prices ranged from about $275,000 to $455,000.

Redfin noted that buying at the wrong time was painful for both generations, but baby boomers had a better chance to recover.

It said that falling rates throughout the late 1980s, 1990s, and early 2000s gave them many opportunities to refinance into lower payments. Millennials who bought before 2022 secured historically low mortgages; those who bought later—or never managed to buy—face a much less forgiving market.

It’s possible the market could become more forgiving for millennials over time, and rates may eventually fall enough that many millennials have the opportunity to refinance into lower payments.

Millennials’ Early Homebuying Advantage

In their early 30s, older millennials who bought a home spent a smaller share of their income on housing than boomers did at the same age, despite much higher home prices, Redfin said. Take the case of a median-earning millennial born in 1984 who bought a home at age 30.

They would have spent roughly 27% of their income to buy the typical home, within the “don’t spend more than 30% of your income on housing costs” rule of thumb, Redfin said.

The brokerage noted two factors helped: cheap borrowing and higher household incomes.

It said millennials benefited from roughly a decade of historically low mortgage rates; they fell below 3% in 2021. Also, millennials tend to have higher household incomes than boomers did at the same age.

For example, Redfin said that at age 37, the typical elder millennial household earned an average of $100,000, compared with $88,000 when boomers were that age. The brokerage noted that the discrepancy is partly because two-income households are more common today.

It said roughly 78% of women participate in the U.S. workforce, up from roughly 60% in 1980. And it should be noted that millennials typically work similar hours for more money than baby boomers at the same life stage.

The Math Changed

Redfin noted that mortgage rates rose from around 3% in late 2021 to nearly 7% in late 2022, after home prices had surged about 40% nationwide during the pandemic homebuying frenzy. It said rising rates often cool prices, but at that time, prices didn’t fall.

The brokerage said that mix of high prices and mortgage rates that had doubled from their pandemic-era low meant Americans had to spend a much higher share of their income to buy a home.

Now what about that same millennial, born in 1984: If they bought a home at age 40 instead of 30, their housing costs shot up to about 35% of their income, Redfin said.

Rising prices and rates also priced many Americans completely out of the housing market, which is why elder millennials have a lower homeownership rate than baby boomers at the same age.

“For millennials who haven’t yet bought a home, affordability is a challenge. But it’s important to remember that you’re not trying to climb Mount Everest; you’re just trying to get back to 2018 or 2019, which was the last time the average homebuyer was spending just about 30% of their income on housing,” said Chen Zhao, Redfin’s Head of Economics. “Before the pandemic, younger generations actually had it easier than the ones before them. But then home prices surged during the pandemic homebuying frenzy and mortgage rates shot up, while incomes kept growing at a normal pace—and the advantage flipped. If you bought in 2020 or 2021, you’re coming out ahead, but those years were the exception, not the rule. One piece of hope for younger Americans who haven’t yet bought a home: Home prices are already falling in parts of the U.S., and they’re softening in others, which means we could be headed back to 2018 or 2019 levels sooner rather than later.”

Redfin noted that millennials are also contending with other major expenses; childcare costs are squeezing them particularly hard. A recent Redfin analysis found that housing and childcare consume more than half of the typical American’s household income.

Adult Gen Zers, who are in their 20s, are tracking behind millennials at the same stage of life, Redfin said. Gen Zers have spent anywhere from 40% of 60% of their income to buy the typical home since they’ve reached homebuying age, the brokerage said.

Partly, that’s because they’re still young enough that they haven’t yet hit their earnings peak, so their current income is lower than older generations, and partly because housing costs are higher than in the past.

Baby Boomers Got Relief

Baby boomers faced their own affordability crisis when they were young, in the 1980s, Redfin reported. In their early 20s, the typical boomer household that bought a home would have spent more than 60% of its income on housing costs. That reflects that era’s runaway inflation and double-digit mortgage rates.

But their housing burden fell quickly as they aged, Redfin noted, falling to around 40% of income by their late 20s and 26% by their late 30s. Baby boomers’ homeownership rate rose from about half in 1985 to over 70% by the late 1990s, and it continued to climb. By their 40s and 50s, the share of homebuyers’ income spent on housing had settled into the low-to-mid 20% range, Redfin said.

Much of the relief for boomers came from the same force that had hurt them at first. As rates gradually declined through the 1980s and 1990s, letting many boomers refinance into far more manageable payments even as home prices kept climbing.

Millennials haven’t had the same opportunity.

Redfin said that those who bought homes before 2022 locked in historically low rates, while those who bought later faced a costly combination of high prices and climbing rates.

It said that would-be buyers who couldn’t afford that combination were left out altogether.

“The housing market has historically been better for baby boomers than younger generations because lower home prices and higher rates are preferable to higher home prices and lower rates,” Zhao said. “You can refinance your rate into a lower housing payment, and that’s exactly what boomers did: They refinanced for up to 40 years as rates kept falling. Then home prices soared, which is why a lot of boomers are rich in real estate.”

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *