Chase should lead the country out of the housing crisis

- Key insight: By following its own historical example, JPMorganChase can help address the nation’s affordable housing crisis and transform community reinvestment.
- Supporting data: With $5 trillion in assets, the bank’s holding company, JPMorgan Chase & Co., is larger than the combined assets of the 4,100 smallest banks.
- Forward look: Using its marketing infrastructure and national reach, Chase could recognize every bank, including competitors, receiving an Outstanding CRA rating each month.
Processing Content
Not imposed by Congress or collected by the IRS. And, not imposed by New York City or any other municipality.
It’s a leadership tax.
This leadership tax comes with the privilege of being the dominant player in an industry where a corporate titan’s responsibility goes beyond shareholders and requires ecosystem stewardship.
It not only demands a willingness to protect the industry’s public standing but also a mandate to help improve industry efforts to address social problems, the biggest today being affordable housing.
My first
With
Chase’s enormous scale, profitability and influence create an opportunity to do something no other American bank can do: use its unrivaled position to help transform how the industry serves low- and moderate-income communities.
There is historical precedent for this leadership tax, coming from none other than the bank’s namesake founder and architect of modern finance,
Before the Fed’s 1913 creation, he effectively acted as
That was a different century and a different crisis.
Chase is not being asked to rescue the financial system or solve the affordable housing crisis.
The ask is narrower: use its institutional resources and marketing platform to make outstanding community reinvestment performance visible, so other banks treat it as something worth doing.
By way of disclosure, I have no business or other interest in Chase besides a bank account.
Chase is uniquely positioned for this mission, not only because of its industry dominance, but because of its proven community reinvestment record.
I
This reflects two definitions of community banking. One, shared by the industry and its
When Chase announced plans to open 100 branches in “
Chase walks the CRA walk rather than talking the CRA talk. Call it “
Chase has a once-in-a-generation opportunity to use this record and take a leadership role by encouraging thousands of banks to make community reinvestment a priority.
Read more:
How exactly would Chase pay this leadership tax?
By using its enormous marketing power as it currently does with the NFL, the
Regular-season NFL games averaged
Recognizing this unparalleled reach, Chase spends millions as official sponsor of the NFL RedZone’s incredibly popular
Why couldn’t Chase apply that same approach to community reinvestment?
Every month, federal banking regulators release CRA ratings, but only about 10% are Outstanding “touchdowns.” For example, there were just seven Outstanding ratings announced in September and 10 in August.
Yet, these achievements, representing three or more years of community commitment, receive little public recognition. Some banks celebrate their own Outstanding ratings, but the rest of the industry and regulators move on.
I spent more than 30 years encouraging federal regulators to publicize Outstanding ratings through a
Forget the government and trades, and imagine a Chase-sponsored “Every CRA Touchdown” program.
Using its marketing infrastructure and national reach, Chase could recognize every bank, including competitors, receiving an Outstanding CRA rating each month.
Like the classic
Instead of spectacular one-handed end-zone receptions or pick-sixes, this program could highlight successful affordable housing projects, first-time homebuyer programs, and other innovative approaches meeting the credit needs of underserved communities.
Highlighting its own competitors with Outstanding CRA ratings would demonstrate leadership, putting industry achievements ahead of its own. Instead of surrendering a competitive advantage, Chase would be encouraging banks to compete more visibly on community reinvestment.
Recognizing successful community development initiatives would help other institutions identify approaches worth replicating. CRA imitation is the best form of flattery.
At a time when affordable housing remains beyond the reach of millions of Americans, the public needs to know that banks, especially the winning 10%, are doing their very best to help.
Chase’s CRA highlight reel, using a combination of traditional and social media, would have relatively minimal costs because it already has the marketing machinery and national platform.
By encouraging the industry to promote affordable housing in this manner, Chase would be repeating its corporate history of helping the country by doing what the government and trades have not.
Chase would be following the example of